NEW YORK METS MANIA

We don’t need AI to know who is the best New York Mets third baseman in history

Who is the best third baseman in Mets history? It shouldn’t take much to figure that out…and we certainly don’t need AI.

It is, though, a seemingly reasonable question to ask especially when it is the off season and when there is no news to banter or argue about. But while the listed group of five third basemen may not have been exactly legitimate because of their statistical history, the legitimacy fell off the cliff simply by looking at the pictures of the five players proposed for that question.

You have to ask yourself “Why?” Why are we so desperate as a society to use AI rather than our own brains, especially when the subject matter is supposed to be fun? So often we see that AI has gotten SOMETHING wrong, so OBVIOUSLY wrong, that you have to wonder if the person presenting is even paying attention, knows what they are doing, or is some chooch sitting at a keyboard simply posting content to draw attention?

Well…aside from the obvious…let’s take this opportunity to look at the five players proposed for this question about Mets third basemen:

Ed Charles

The Glider. Ed Charles came to the Mets later in his career but he gave the Mets clutch play, professionalism, and leadership. He was a key member of the 1969 World Championship team and he was a member of the organization in many capacities for the rest of his life. Why is he forgotten?

He spent 2 ½ seasons as a Met, arriving in 1967. In 1968, he played in 117 games and hit a team-leading 15 home runs while batting .276. He had that rare combination of power and speed, but at 35 years old, he was already on the downside of his career. He played in only 61 games in 1969 during the regular season (sharing time with Wayne Garrett and Bobby Pfeil), hitting a career low .207 and 3 home runs, but came up with clutch hits in his limited time and was one of the leaders and most loved person on that ’69 team.

Wayne Garrett

Wayne Garrett would spend 7+ seasons in a Mets uniform, one of the longest tenured Mets to play the position. He was a very active part of the 1969 World Series Championship team at the age of 21, mainly because he was a Rule 5 pick-up and so he had to remain on the active roster or sent back to the Atlanta Braves. He not only shared third base with Ed Charles, but he played shortstop for Bud Harrelson and second base for Ken Boswell while they were respectively away for their military commitments during that season.

Garrett had a strong 1970 campaign, in 114 games he hit 12 home runs with a .254 batting average, but walked 81 times for an OBP of .390. His best season was 1973 when he established himself as the team’s leadoff hitter and batted .256 with 16 home runs during that “Ya Gotta Believe!” season.

The thing about Wayne Garrett was that the Mets never fully bought into him. They annually brought in right handed options after Ed Charles retired following the 1969 season – Joe Foy (1970), Bob Aspromonte (1971), Jim Fregosi (1972), Joe Torre (1975), Roy Staiger (1976).

Howard Johnson

HoJo was one of the most talented and dynamic players to ever don a Mets uniform. He obviously had that combination of power and speed which was proven by the fact that he was a member of the 30-30 club three out of five season – 1987, 1989, 1991.

But then the Mets ruined him. At one time they tried to move a centerfielder to third base – Amos Otis – and that didn’t work. Otis, though, would go on to be an All Star centerfielder for years. This time, in 1992, the Mets tried to do the opposite…move a third baseman to centerfield. The fact that future Hall of Famers Robin Yount and Craig Biggio were both able to make the move to centerfield made the Mets front office confident that it would be a smart move. It wasn’t. And Howard Johnson at 31 years of age would never again be even remotely close to the player he was before that. He played 9 seasons for the Mets with 192 HR and 202 SB.

Robin Ventura

Robin Ventura signed with the Mets after spending 10 productive seasons with the Chisox. He would spend three seasons in a Mets uniform, his best season was his first – 1999. Ventura hit .301 with 32 HR and 109 RBI. He would be a part of probably what was the best offensive team in Mets history. He would also be a part of the best defensive infield in Mets history, along with shortstop Rey Ordonez, second baseman Edgardo Alfonso, and first baseman John Olerud. They were famously featured on the cover of Sports Illustrated in the iconic black jerseys.

Venture would a be a part of the 2000 World Series…Subway Series against that Yankees, but his production would begin to fade in the second and third season with the Mets. He would go on to play for the Yankees after leaving the Mets following the 2001 season.

David Wright

What can you say about David Wright? He was the ultimate guy that you would want to play for your team. He was the only “home-grown” Met…actually drafted by the team…to come up through the farm system…and become an All Star…and play his entire career with the team. While it’s true that Ed Kranepool and Ron Hodges never played for another team, they also never established themselves as a superstar the way Wright did with the New York Mets.

Wright spent a total of 13 seasons (the last two were decimated by the spinal stenosis where he managed to play only 75 games before being forced to retire) with the organization. He batted .296 with an OBP of .376, he hit 242 HR and stole 196 bases. Like his mentor HoJo, Wright had that rare combination of power and speed and joined him as a member of the 30-30 club in 2007.

Wright was named captain of the Mets and rightfully had his No. 5 retired by the club.

There are some other players – in addition to some already mentioned – who manned the hot corner for the Mets over the years – some of whom you may not even recall, and some you may WANT to not recall:

Don Zimmer, Ken Boyer, Elliott Maddox, Lenny Randle, Richie Hebner, Hubie Brooks, Bobby Bonilla, Jeff Kent, Eric Campbell, Todd Frazier But to answer the original question…by far and away…David Wright is the best third baseman…and perhaps the best all-around player in Mets history…and it doesn’t take a rocket scientist…OR AI…to figure that one out.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest from Alan Karmin

Archives

Alan Karmin is an award-winning journalist and author. He was born in Brooklyn, New York and spent most of his life growing up in the New Jersey suburbs. Alan's family were avid Brooklyn Dodgers fans and when the Dodgers moved west, the Mets became the team to root for. The Mets have always been a true focal point, Alan even wrote a term paper in high school to analyze what was wrong with the Mets. While at the University of Miami, Alan honed his craft covering the, gulp, Yankees during spring trainings in Fort Lauderdale for a local NBC affiliate, as well as the Associated Press and UPI. He broadcasted baseball games for the University of Miami, and spring training games for the Baltimore Orioles and Montreal Expos. New York Mets Mania is a forum for Alan to write about his favorite team and for baseball fans to chime in and provide their thoughts and ideas about New York's Amazin' Mets.